Iowa’s Proposed PL 86-272 Rulemaking Would Bring the MTC’s Internet-Nexus Theory to Iowa

Iowa’s Proposed PL 86-272 Rulemaking Would Bring the MTC’s Internet-Nexus Theory to Iowa

Posted on 11/17/2026 at 09:26 AM by Cody Edwards

Background on PL 86-272

Public Law 86-272 is a federal safe harbor that limits a state’s ability to impose a net income tax on an out-of-state seller whose in-state activity is limited to soliciting orders for sales of tangible personal property. To qualify, the orders must be sent outside the state for approval or rejection and, if approved, filled by shipment or delivery from outside the state. The statute does not protect sales of services, real estate, or intangibles, and it does not protect corporations incorporated in the taxing state or individuals domiciled or resident there.

The Supreme Court’s key interpretation in Wisconsin Department of Revenue v. Wrigley held that “solicitation” includes activities entirely ancillary to requests for orders, but not activities that serve an independent business function apart from solicitation. That distinction is important because PL 86-272 is an all-or-nothing protection: more-than-de-minimis unprotected activity can cause the taxpayer to lose immunity for the state’s net income tax.

The MTC’s Internet-Era Interpretation

The Multistate Tax Commission’s 2021 statement applies the traditional PL 86-272 framework to internet activity. The MTC treats a business’s interaction with customers through a website or app as business activity in the customer’s state, while preserving protection for static content and functions entirely ancillary to solicitation. In the MTC’s view, a basic e-commerce website can remain protected if it merely lets customers search for tangible goods, read descriptions, select items, choose delivery options, and pay.

The MTC treats many common website features as unprotected. Examples include post-sale chat or email support, certain analytics cookies, remote product fixes, extended warranty sales, and marketplace inventory. Critics argue that this approach effectively narrows PL 86-272 for ordinary e-commerce sellers and relies too heavily on Wayfair, which was not a PL 86-272 case.

Iowa’s Proposed Rule

Iowa’s proposed rulemaking, RA 26-399, would move Iowa in the same direction. The Iowa Department of Revenue proposes to rescind and readopt Chapter 501, which governs corporate income tax filing rules. The Department says the proposal updates Rule 701—501.1 to address “more modern methods of doing business” for nexus and PL 86-272 purposes.

The proposal defines “within Iowa” to include activities carried on in Iowa or directed at Iowa customers. It also states that traditional physical presence is not necessarily required. Most importantly, the definition expressly includes online activities through websites or applications that are directed at Iowa customers.

Protected and Unprotected Activities Under the Iowa Proposal

The Iowa examples largely track the MTC statement. Iowa would continue to protect solicitation, advertising, sales-related meetings, static website FAQs, shopping-cart cookies, and basic e-commerce functionality. Those examples are consistent with the MTC’s view that static information and solicitation-ancillary ordering functions do not defeat PL 86-272.

Iowa would treat several common digital functions as unprotected. Those include post-sale chat or email support, online branded-credit-card applications, analytics cookies used for inventory or product development, remote product fixes, extended warranty sales, Iowa marketplace-facilitator inventory, and streaming. The proposal also states that activities after a sale ordinarily will not be entirely ancillary to requests for purchases. That sentence may draw comments because it could be read more broadly than the specific MTC examples.

The Department’s Regulatory Analysis Understates Taxpayer Costs

The Department’s Regulatory Analysis says the proposed rule has no meaningful taxpayer cost, no significant quantitative impact, no anticipated revenue effect, and no substantial small-business impact. That conclusion is hard to reconcile with the rule’s text. The proposal would treat online activity directed at Iowa customers as activity “within Iowa,” even without traditional physical presence. That change requires remote sellers to revisit whether they have Iowa nexus and whether PL 86-272 still protects them.

The compliance burden is practical, not theoretical. Businesses would need to review website chat, email support, cookies, customer data use, extended warranties, remote product updates, marketplace inventory, and other common digital functions. That review will often require input from tax, legal, IT, marketing, customer service, and marketplace teams. For small and midsize sellers that rely on standardized e-commerce platforms and third-party plug-ins, state-by-state customization may be costly or impractical.

At minimum, the Department should acknowledge these compliance costs and consider prospective-only application, transition relief, and clearer safe harbors for low-risk website functions.

The Independent-Contractor Issue in Iowa’s Proposed Rule

The proposed rule’s independent-contractor language deserves close attention. PL 86-272 expressly provides that the term “representative” does not include an independent contractor. The statute separately protects sales, solicitation, and office maintenance by qualifying independent contractors when their activities on behalf of the seller are limited to making sales or soliciting orders for tangible personal property.

Iowa’s proposal defines “representative” to include independent contractors, agents, brokers, and others acting on behalf of or at the direction of the corporation. Standing alone, that definition appears to blur a distinction Congress made explicit. The proposal partially fixes the issue later by stating that independent contractors and similar persons can destroy immunity if they perform non-de-minimis nonsolicitation activities in Iowa. It also states that an independent contractor’s maintenance of an office in Iowa or making of sales in Iowa does not remove PL 86-272 protection.

Read as a whole, Iowa likely intends to preserve the federal independent-contractor safe harbor while denying protection when a contractor performs unprotected activities such as repairs, returns, warranty work, or other post-sale services. Still, the Department could reduce ambiguity by revising the definition of “representative” to say that it includes independent contractors only except as otherwise protected by PL 86-272.

Litigation in Other States

Litigation in other states shows where Iowa disputes may head. California’s MTC-style guidance was challenged by the American Catalog Mailers Association as contrary to PL 86-272, as an improper underground regulation, and as retroactive in violation of due process. Reporting indicates the California guidance was invalidated on administrative-procedure grounds.

New York adopted its rules through formal regulation, making it a closer analogue to Iowa. New York courts upheld the regulation against a facial preemption challenge while barring retroactive application. Iowa’s formal rulemaking process may reduce procedural risk, but it does not eliminate potential disputes over retroactivity, statutory conflict, or application to specific taxpayer facts.

Practical Takeaways

Remote sellers of tangible personal property into Iowa should map their Iowa-facing website functions, cookies, customer-service channels, warranty offerings, remote update processes, and marketplace inventory arrangements. They should also review whether any Iowa contractors qualify as independent contractors under PL 86-272 and whether those contractors perform only protected activities.

Public comments may be especially useful on four points. The first is the breadth of the definition of “within Iowa”. The second is the proposed treatment of post-sale activities. The third is the absence of an express retroactivity limitation. The fourth is the definition of “representative,” which should be clarified to preserve PL 86-272’s independent-contractor distinction.

Bottom Line

Iowa’s proposal is not just a technical rewrite. It would align Iowa with the MTC’s view that common digital interactions can defeat PL 86-272 protection, even without traditional physical presence. The proposal is strongest where it applies Wrigley’s solicitation-versus-independent-business-function test. It is most vulnerable where its state-law definitions, especially the definition of “representative,” risk conflicting with the federal statute’s separate treatment of independent contractors.

 

 

Questions, Contact us today.

Contact Us

 


The material, whether written or oral (including videos) that is posted on the various blogs of Dickinson Bradshaw is not intended, nor should it be construed or relied upon, as legal advice. The opinions expressed in the various blog posting are those of the individual author, they may not reflect the opinions of the firm.  Your use of the Dickinson Bradshaw blog postings does NOT create an attorney-client relationship between you and Dickinson, Bradshaw, Fowler & Hagen, P.C. or any of its attorneys.  If specific legal information is needed, please retain and consult with an attorney of your own selection.

Comments
There are no comments yet.
Add Comment

* Indicates a required field